Danielle Peterson, a former dermatology resident, has filed a federal lawsuit against NYC Health and Hospitals, alleging a pattern of gender-based discrimination and harassment that ultimately led to their removal from the residency program at Metropolitan Hospital Center in Manhattan.
Sources:
gothamist.comlgbtqnation.comThe lawsuit, submitted on March 23, claims violations of both state and city human rights laws, specifically citing gender identity discrimination, disability discrimination, and retaliation.
Source:
gothamist.comPeterson alleges that the program's director, Dr Marian Russo, instructed them to keep their nonbinary identity and pronouns secret, effectively creating a condition of employment that mandated concealment of their gender identity.
Source:
lgbtqnation.comThe complaint details a workplace atmosphere rife with hostility and discrimination.For instance, Department Chair Dr Bijan Safai allegedly expressed skepticism regarding Peterson's credentials, claiming they had "tricked" the program during the interview process.
Source:
hcamag.comAdditionally, faculty members reportedly made derogatory comments about nonbinary individuals, with one faculty member asking how Peterson could ascertain a patient's gender and jokingly referring to transgender individuals as "perverts.".
Sources:
gothamist.comlgbtqnation.comThe situation escalated in November 2024 when Dr Safai demanded that Peterson undergo an internal psychiatric evaluation, suggesting that there was "something mentally wrong" with them.This demand reportedly followed Peterson's disclosure of their nonbinary identity during a confrontation with Dr Safai, who allegedly responded with an inappropriate anecdote about a transgender man, implying that Peterson would become "ugly" if they transitioned.
Sources:
hcamag.comlgbtqnation.comDespite seeking external evaluations from two independent doctors who cleared Peterson for clinical duties, they were removed from all responsibilities for a month.
Source:
hcamag.comPeterson's lawsuit highlights procedural irregularities, such as the lack of a Performance Improvement Plan, which goes against the institution's own policies.
Source:
gothamist.comThe complaint also notes that Peterson was denied access to their personnel file, a right they were entitled to under their contract, which raises further questions about the institution's adherence to proper HR procedures.
Sources:
hcamag.comlgbtqnation.comThe final decision to not renew Peterson's contract was made on April 24, 2025, citing unsatisfactory completion of a remediation plan and a lack of professionalism, despite evidence suggesting that this plan was not communicated effectively or in a timely manner.
Sources:
hcamag.comgothamist.comAs part of the lawsuit, Peterson is seeking damages and has requested a jury trial.The actions outlined in their complaint reflect broader issues regarding workplace discrimination against nonbinary and transgender individuals, particularly within medical and educational institutions.
Sources:
gothamist.comnyc.govNYC Health and Hospitals has yet to respond publicly to the lawsuit.
Source:
lgbtqnation.comThis case underscores the ongoing challenges faced by nonbinary individuals in professional settings, particularly in fields such as medicine, where inclusion and respect for gender identity are crucial for fostering a supportive work environment.
Sources:
gothamist.comnyc.govIn New York City, discrimination based on gender identity is prohibited under the New York City Human Rights Law, which aims to protect individuals from harassment and discrimination in various domains, including employment.
Source:
nyc.govThe outcome of this lawsuit could have significant implications for policies regarding gender identity and inclusion in medical institutions moving forward.
