The Montgomery County Board of Education in Maryland has been mandated to pay $1.5 million to a coalition of religious parents following a ruling by the US Supreme Court concerning parental rights in education.This decision arises from a lawsuit initiated by a diverse group of parents, including Muslims, Christians, and Jews, who opposed the school district's introduction of LGBTQ+-themed instructional materials without parental consent.
Sources:
marylandmatters.orgbecketfund.orgThe Supreme Court ruled on the case, Mahmoud v.Taylor, in June 2025, stating that the right of parents to guide their children's religious upbringing extends into public school classrooms.
Sources:
becketfund.orgdailycitizen.focusonthefamily.comThe court emphasized that parental rights would be undermined if schools could dictate educational content without notifying parents, thereby infringing upon their First Amendment rights.
Sources:
dailycitizen.focusonthefamily.comwjla.comThe financial settlement and accompanying injunction were confirmed by US District Judge Deborah L.Boardman, who noted that the Montgomery County Board of Education must now provide advance notice to parents whenever instructional materials addressing family life and human sexuality will be used in the classroom.Parents will also retain the right to opt their children out of such instruction if it conflicts with their religious beliefs.
Sources:
marylandmatters.orgchristianpost.comEric Baxter, senior counsel at the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and lead attorney for the parents, expressed that this ruling serves as a significant victory for parental rights.He stated, “Public schools nationwide are on notice: running roughshod over parental rights and religious freedom isn't just illegal—it's costly.”.
Sources:
becketfund.orgdailycitizen.focusonthefamily.comThe case originated in the 2022-2023 academic year when Montgomery County schools introduced various LGBTQ+-themed books into their curricula for grades as early as pre-kindergarten.Some of these books included titles such as "Born Ready," which tells the story of a child identifying as a boy, and "Jacob's Room to Choose," which addresses transgender issues.
Source:
marylandmatters.orgThe school initially allowed parents to opt their children out of certain health education classes but later revoked this option for language arts classes, prompting the lawsuit.
Sources:
marylandmatters.orgchristianpost.comThe Supreme Court's majority opinion, written by Justice Samuel Alito, highlighted the importance of parental oversight in children's education, stating, “The right of parents to direct the religious upbringing of their children would be an empty promise if it did not follow those children into the public school classroom.” This ruling is seen as a pivotal moment for parental rights, especially in the context of religious objections to educational content.
Sources:
becketfund.orgdailycitizen.focusonthefamily.comIn addition to financial damages, the settlement requires the Montgomery County Board of Education to implement ongoing procedures ensuring that parents are adequately informed about the materials being used in classrooms.This includes sending out emails before each marking period detailing the instructional materials approved for each grade level.
Sources:
marylandmatters.orgchristianpost.comMontgomery County Public Schools has indicated that it is already taking steps to comply with the court's mandate and has revised its opt-out process.A spokesperson stated that the school system aims to improve its responsiveness to parents and to foster a partnership between families and the school district.
Source:
marylandmatters.orgThe implications of this ruling extend beyond Montgomery County, as it sets a precedent for other school districts across the country regarding parental rights and the inclusion of LGBTQ+ content in curricula.As Eric Baxter noted, this decision could encourage other parents to assert their rights in similar situations, reinforcing the importance of parental involvement in educational content.
Sources:
becketfund.orgdailycitizen.focusonthefamily.comThe settlement reached between the Montgomery County Board of Education and the parents marks a significant development in the ongoing conversation about educational content and parental rights in the United States.With the legal battles concluded, both parties now look to the future and the steps necessary to rebuild trust between the school district and the families it serves.
