Trump's DOJ Election Probe Faces Court Challenge in Fulton County

Mar 28, 2026, 2:20 AM

Hover over text to view sources

The Justice Department's investigation into the 2020 election faced its first public court test in Atlanta as Fulton County officials challenged the legality of a federal search warrant used to seize election materials. This unprecedented move by the DOJ has raised concerns about the implications for future elections, with county officials warning that it could embolden similar actions during election years.

During a five-hour hearing, Judge JP Boulee heard arguments regarding the warrant's validity, with Fulton County's lawyer, Abbe Lowell, highlighting that the FBI's affidavit failed to provide evidence of intentional wrongdoing. Lowell argued that the affidavit contained "incoherent" and "contradictory" descriptions of election procedures, and lacked a clear target in the investigation.

Witness Ryan Macias, a former election security expert, testified that the alleged irregularities cited by the FBI were common administrative anomalies that occur during elections and do not indicate fraud. He criticized the FBI for relying on statements from conspiracy theorists and election deniers rather than on concrete evidence.

The DOJ maintained that Fulton County had not met the high threshold required to return the seized materials, arguing that the county needed to demonstrate a "callous disregard" for constitutional rights. Tysen Duva, head of the DOJ's criminal division, emphasized that the agency's investigations were entitled to broad latitude, stating, "This is not grading a paper," when questioned about the affidavit's quality.

The hearing also explored the timing of the warrant, with Lowell contending that the DOJ sought it despite ongoing civil litigation over the same records. This raised questions about the motivations behind the warrant, leading to speculation that it was pursued to circumvent delays in the civil case.

Judge Boulee expressed skepticism towards the DOJ's arguments while also noting that the county's discomfort with the investigation did not constitute a constitutional claim. He indicated that if evidence emerged suggesting the DOJ sought the warrant to bypass civil litigation, it would bolster the county's position.

The case's backdrop includes the involvement of Kurt Olsen, a lawyer associated with Trump's efforts to challenge the 2020 election results, who reportedly instigated the DOJ's investigation. This connection has raised alarms about the integrity of the probe, as it appears driven by political motivations rather than legitimate concerns over election security.

Amidst the legal wrangling, the DOJ provided Fulton County with digital copies of the seized ballots, but officials argue that retaining the original materials is crucial to ensure their integrity against ongoing efforts to delegitimize the 2020 results.

As the court deliberates, the implications of this case extend beyond Fulton County, with experts warning that a ruling in favor of the DOJ could set a troubling precedent for the treatment of election materials in future elections.

The judge did not issue a ruling at the conclusion of the hearing, leaving the fate of the seized ballots and the broader implications of the DOJ's investigation uncertain as the legal battle continues.

Trump Orders Immediate Pay for TSA Workers Amid Shutdown

President Trump has issued an executive order to ensure Transportation Security Administration (TSA) workers are paid during the ongoing government shutdown. This order comes as Congress struggles to reach a funding agreement, resulting in significant airport delays and employee hardships.

GOP Loss in Trump's Mar-a-Lago District Signals Trouble Ahead

Democrat Emily Gregory's surprising victory in a special election for a Florida House seat that includes Trump's Mar-a-Lago estate raises concerns for the GOP ahead of the midterm elections. This upset highlights a broader trend of Democratic overperformance in various elections, indicating potential challenges for Republicans as they prepare for November.

Black Troops and the Legacy of White Violence in the Postbellum South

A recent study examines the impact of Black military occupation on patterns of white supremacist violence in the post-Civil War South. It reveals that counties previously occupied by Black troops experienced significantly higher rates of lynching and racial violence following the withdrawal of federal forces, highlighting the long-term consequences of military interventions.

Trump Housing Official Targets AG Letitia James with New Referrals

Bill Pulte, a top housing official under President Trump, has issued new criminal referrals against New York Attorney General Letitia James, alleging mortgage fraud. James's attorney has condemned the actions as politically motivated, following previous unsuccessful attempts to charge her.

Wisconsin Supreme Court Debate Postponed Due to Candidate's Illness

The Wisconsin Supreme Court debate originally set for March 25 has been postponed after candidate Chris Taylor fell ill with kidney stones. The event is now rescheduled for April 2, just days before the election on April 7.